pat cumminsImage Credits: IG/@patcummins30

After Durban, Australian fans rejoiced. Pat Cummins suddenly seemed to wash off his one-off blip against Bangladesh. But 2 tests later, Australia is leaving South Africa with defeat, with questions all over his position. Not to mention the unstable batting order and an ageing bowling attack. Now with Ashes on the horizon, the fans would be wondering – is Cummins the right man for the job?

Is Pat Cummins the Bowler Disposable, What About Pat Cummins the Captain? 

Cummins’ returns dwindled as the series wore on and the tracks changed. The fans could see him operating with his trademark control. Maintaining an economic baseline.

At Kingsmead, Cummins was sharp. Incisive. Exploiting every bit of moisture or movement. Returning 3/54, setting the tone, and keeping the Proteas’ batting order under check. Second innings? Highly economical and disciplined, with 2.43 economy. 

The result? A 1-0 advantage against South Africa. Then the Proteas bounced back, humiliating Cummins’ men with an innings-and-31-run defeat. Cummins’ return? Toiled for 26 overs, 3.69 economy, no wickets. 

Pat Cummins
Image Credits: IG/@patcummins30

At Newlands, Cummins bowled 42 overs, taking only 2 wickets. Struggling to get early breakthroughs. He overall lacked the bite – no surprise attack. While that largely was due to the pitches’ nature. His role as a tactician took a hit as well. 

Newlands might be one test that Cummins would want to forget. Winning the toss and opting to bowl. Taking a decision that stood in stark contrast to history and legends like Herschelle Gibbs, who repeatedly said, you bat first, no matter what. 

It worked in his favour for a while. Especially after Australia took a massive 100-run lead. But when you bat on Day 5 on a turning pitch, even 150 is hard to chase. That’s what happened.

Then the fans could see how Cummins stuck to his templates, rather than adapting as a captain. When Simon Harmer began exploring turn and rough patches, Cameron Green was shielded by the lower order. Alex Carey got out playing a reserve sweep. 

Who is asking questions about temperament? Was it Cummins’ decision to play Green on a turning track even when he can’t handle spin? 

Then there is the glaring issue of Cummins’ struggle to tackle South Africa’s tail. Second test, the Proteas had lost 6 wickets at 110; they went on to declare at 425-9. Third test, South Africa were effectively at 81-5 (after deducting the lead) in the second innings. Eventually setting a target of 288. 

Field placements were too defensive once a partnership settled, and the Kangaroos paid a heavy price. All stemming from bad tactical decisions. 

So, What Happens With Pat Cummins?

Cummins’ captaincy will be tested once again when Australia welcomes New Zealand. All decisions will be heavily scrutinised. But what happens if Australia sweeps the series and then gets decimated by India 5-0? That will leave a very small period to make the adjustments ahead of the Ashes. 

Marnus Labuschagne’s 49th consecutive innings without a Test ton.

Fall from grace is an understatement. 10 centuries in his first 30 Tests, and just one in his next 39. It’s all but done for him. Can Sam Konstas do a better job?

#SAvAUS #CricketTwitter #Cricket— Bharat SportsWire (@Bharatsportswre) October 31, 2026

Cummins the bowler is still a quality pick, but he sometimes allows his fatigue to catch up to him, fogging his decision-making as a captain, too.

What Changes Are Exactly Needed for Australia To Change the Narrative?

Marcus Labuschagne is the perfect scapegoat. He needs to go. Since his last test hundred in July 2023, he walked out to the pitch 49 times. Scoring 1094 at 24.31 average. Single-digit score? 22. He was a walking wicket, putting the middle order in peril. 

Then there is the lower-order conundrum. Apart from Alex Carey, no one seems to hold the ground. We all see Cameron Green and Cooper Connolly looking clueless. Matt Renshaw is the new top order now. Leaving a couple of big gaps. Number 3 and Number 7, with Beau Webster and Connolly’s experience failing.

Then you can make a case about Scott Boland. That’s another tactical blunder that Cummins made. You don’t have any quality spinner, as Nathan Lyon was exposed on a spinning track where Simon Harmer bagged a 6-wicket haul. 

So, the question is, can you insert and trust Sam Konstas at 3? Then what happens to 7? Green doesn’t seem to work. Leaving the whole batting order quite vulnerable. 

Marnus Labuschagne
Image Credits: IG/@marnus3

Then the pace quadrant has only a couple of quality years left in them. Yes, they can surpass physical limits and continue for long.

But can you expect that consistency from Mitchell Starc (37), Josh Hazlewood (35), Lyon (38), and Boland (37)?

Michael Neser is also 36. Jhye Richardson, 30, has been dropped from the central contract. Lane Morris never seemed his original self after sustained injuries. Only 2 names remain after filtering out medical history and age: Fergus O’Neill and Mahli Beardman, who have yet to get decent international exposure. 

How Is England Shaping Up Ahead of Ashes?

Now, compare that with Joe Root and Stephen Fleming’s Three Lions. Josh Tongue has been a revelation, with a 16.32 average and a 19.89 strike rate during the Pakistan series.

Then you have Jofra Archer and Mark Wood, who are going to trouble this Australian unsettled batting lineup. Harry Brook is the big thing in cricket, and Joe Root is going to be the anchor around which the English team is going to revolve. 

What Could Happen If Ashes Were Played Today?

England would be clear favourites. That’s an understatement still. Australia’s psychological scars from the South African collapse and the Bangladesh shocker, combined with a brittle top order and a weary bowling attack. It’s a recipe for disaster.

This is a wake-up call for Australia. Cummins had to make some tough calls, and that starts with him. However, that also puts George Bailey and Andrew McDonald under the scanner. So, the stakes are higher. New Zealand test series might help the fans get some answers, and those could still be dismantled during the Indian test series.

Some tough times ahead for Australian cricket.

Also Read: ‘I Feel Sad for Him’: Alyssa Healy’s Raw Verdict on Marnus Labuschagne’s Slump

By Rohit Lohan

Rohit is a seasoned sports writer with over four years of professional experience and more than 2,000 published articles under his belt. He is primarily known for his comprehensive and engaging coverage of cricket, offering deep tactical analysis and storytelling that resonates with fans. He holds a bachelor's degree in history from the University of Delhi, which has given him a unique, narrative-driven perspective on sports journalism. Off the pitch, Rohit is usually reading a book or deep into an anime debate.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *